Letter to the editor: Keeping a balanced perspective on the Affordable Care Act

By Ron Pollack /

For most individuals and families in Oregon, the Affordable Care Act makes health coverage better and more affordable. While there will be problems, such as the recent insurance cancellation notices sent to recipients of substandard plans, let’s look at these issues in perspective.

For the almost 1.7 million non-elderly Oregonians with asthma, diabetes, high blood pressure, a history of cancer or other pre-existing health conditions, new protections will become available.

Insurers will no longer be allowed to deny or terminate health coverage due to such pre-existing conditions. And they will be prohibited from charging higher premiums based on health status. This means that Oregonians with the greatest need for health care will now be able to receive it.

Starting on Jan. 1, nearly 401,000 Oregonians will also become eligible for substantial tax-credit subsidies that will make insurance premiums much more affordable. These subsidies will be available for many in the middle class, as well as those with moderate incomes. Eligibility extends to 400 percent of the federal poverty level ($94,200 in annual income for a family of four, $46,000 for an individual living alone). For family coverage, the average annual subsidies, according to the Kaiser Family Foundation, will be $5,548.

Women, especially those of child-bearing age, will not be charged discriminatory higher premiums that often make their health coverage unaffordable.

Young adults, the age group most likely to be uninsured today, will disproportionately benefit from the Affordable Care Act. This is because the tax-credit premium subsidies are provided on a sliding scale — those with the lowest incomes (like young adults continuing their education, without jobs, or in entry-level jobs) will receive the most financial help.

But let’s be clear. These notable achievements do not belie the need to address the concerns of people who have received termination notices from their insurance companies. Those notices were sent to people with private non-group (individual) insurance policies, many of which are substandard — they fail to meet new consumer protection standards. For example, many of these substandard plans place arbitrary limits on how much they will pay out in claims in any year.

Many consider these plans “Swiss cheese” insurance — insurance that doesn’t really insure.

But let’s keep in mind that the vast majority of people receiving these termination notices will not only be able to obtain better coverage but will also qualify for financial help in paying for their new premiums.

In Oregon, for example, most of those in the individual insurance market today — 76 percent — have incomes below 400 percent of the federal poverty line and are therefore eligible for substantial premium subsidies. Once they enroll in new health coverage through the Affordable Care Act, they will be better off than they were before.

And let’s remember how small this potentially vulnerable group is. To begin with, most people with health insurance receive it through their employers, and not many people have individual (non-group) insurance coverage today. Only 7.4 percent of the non-elderly in Oregon currently have individual insurance plans, and not all of them received termination notices.

Research shows that most of these individuals would have moved on to more traditional plans after a year (for example, an employer’s plan), as they did prior to the Affordable Care Act. As a result, only 0.6 percent of Oregonians are at risk staying in the individual market and not receiving a robust premium subsidy under the new law.

This does not mean that addressing the problems of plan cancellations is not important. It is.

But it is equally important for all of us to keep a balanced understanding of the benefits and challenges of the Affordable Care Act. When we do this, we can state the obvious — the new health care law will be an enormous improvement for the vast majority of Oregonians.

— Ron Pollack is the founding executive director of Families USA, the national organization for health care consumers.